Toaster Oven Parts: Genuine Replacements for Optimal Performance

Hey there, did your trusty toaster oven suddenly stop heating up or is it not quite toasting like it used to? Don’t despair, the solution is often easier than you think. Many common toaster oven issues can be fixed by simply replacing one or more parts. The key is sourcing high-quality, genuine replacement parts that are specifically designed for your make and model. Generic or imitation parts just won’t cut it and could be dangerous.

In this article, we’ll walk you through how to find and order the exact Toaster Oven Parts you need to get your toaster oven back in working order. We have researched all the major toaster oven brands and models so you can feel confident you’re getting the right replacement thermostats, heating elements, knobs, trays, and more. Why buy a whole new appliance when a simple part swap will have your trusted toaster oven toasting like new again? Read on to learn how easy and affordable it can be to revive your toaster oven with genuine replacement parts.

Toaster Oven Parts

Toaster Oven Parts

Toaster Oven Parts: Genuine Replacements for Optimal Performance

Heating Elements: The Heart of Your Toaster Oven

The heating element is the part that actually heats up your toaster oven and browns your food. It’s essentially the “heart” of your appliance, so if it’s not working properly, your toaster oven won’t function.

There are a few types of heating elements used in toaster ovens. The most common are made of nickel and chromium, called Nichrome wires. These wires heat up when an electric current passes through them. Ceramic heating elements are also popular and made of a ceramic compound that conducts heat well. Both Nichrome and ceramic elements typically last 3-5 years with normal use before needing replacement.

To test if your heating element has gone bad, first check that the temperature dial or digital display is actually calling for heat. If so, but your toaster oven isn’t heating up, it’s likely the heating element. You may see visible damage like cracks, breaks or holes in the element. It may also make popping, sizzling noises when turned on.

Replacing a heating element yourself isn’t too difficult and can save you money versus paying for a service call. Make sure to unplug the toaster oven, remove any detachable parts like trays or racks and you should have clear access to the element. Note how the old element is installed before removing it, then install the new part in the exact same position. Test your repair by plugging in the toaster oven—it should heat up like new again.

Using genuine replacement parts specifically for your toaster oven model will ensure optimal and safe performance for years to come. Don’t settle for generic or aftermarket parts that could overheat, short out or not fit properly. Genuine parts are worth the investment to restore your toaster oven and keep it working its best.

Thermostats: Maintaining Proper Temperature Control

The thermostat maintains the proper internal temperature in your toaster oven. Without a properly functioning thermostat, the heating elements will continue heating until the oven becomes dangerously hot.

Most toaster ovens have an adjustable thermostat knob or dial that lets you select the desired temperature. As the oven heats up, the thermostat senses the internal temperature and cycles the heating element or elements on and off to maintain the selected temperature.

If your toaster oven is producing undercooked or burnt results, or the internal temperature seems off, the thermostat likely needs replacement. You’ll want to find a genuine OEM thermostat that’s specifically designed for your make and model. Aftermarket or generic thermostats may not have the proper temperature range or sensitivity for your unit.

Replacing the thermostat typically involves disconnecting the wiring from the old thermostat, removing any mounting screws or brackets, and installing the new thermostat. Be very careful working around the heating elements, as they can remain hot for some time after use.

Most DIYers can handle a thermostat replacement, but if you have any doubts or don’t feel comfortable working on electrical appliances, it’s best left to a professional repair technician. Proper temperature control and safety mechanisms are nothing to gamble with.

When shopping for a replacement thermostat, look for key terms like “OEM thermostat,” “genuine replacement part,” and your specific toaster oven make and model number. An exact match will ensure optimal, long-lasting performance from your toaster oven. Isn’t that worth the investment to keep this versatile appliance in working order for years to come?

Knobs, Dials and Switches: Selecting the Right Settings

The knobs, dials and switches on your toaster oven control the cooking temperature and timer. Choosing the proper settings is key to optimal performance and ensuring tasty results.

Temperature Control

The temperature dial or knob allows you to select the internal temperature for baking, broiling or toasting. For most foods, you’ll want to preheat the oven to the desired temperature before adding the food.

As a general rule:

  • Use lower temps (around 300 F) for warming foods or proofing dough.
  • Mid-range temps (350-375 F) are good for baking casseroles, cookies, and reheating leftovers.
  • Higher temps (400 F and up) are best for broiling meats, browning vegetables or toasting bread.
  • The max temp setting (450 F) should only be used for broiling thicker cuts of meat or for a quick blast when broiling. Keep a close eye on the food at such a high heat to avoid burning.
  • For toasting bread, start at a mid-range setting and check on it frequently, lowering the temp as needed. Different bread types toast at different rates.
  • When in doubt, check on the food early—you can always continue cooking, but you can’t undo overcooking! Adjust the temperature setting or cooking time for the next batch.


The timer knob or buttons control how long the oven will cook before shutting off automatically. For most foods, check on them 2-3 minutes before the timer goes off, then continue cooking in short intervals if needed. It’s best to underestimate cooking times, as you can always add more time, but you can’t undo overcooking food!

Using the proper temperature, cooking time and checking on foods regularly will ensure your toaster oven is performing at an optimal level and producing delicious results every time. Be sure to refer to your owner’s manual for specific guidance on using the controls for your make and model.

Racks: Supporting Your Baking Needs

The racks in your toaster oven are essential for supporting your baking and broiling needs. The racks hold your food at the proper height for even cooking. Most toaster ovens come with at least two racks so you can cook multiple items at once or broil a dish at the top while baking another dish below.

Over time, the racks in your toaster oven can become damaged or warped from high heat use. Replacing old, worn out racks is important to ensure optimal performance and safety. Genuine replacement racks are specifically designed for your make and model toaster oven to provide the proper fit and support. Off-brand or generic racks may not fit properly and can affect cooking results.

To find the right replacement racks for your toaster oven, check the owner’s manual for the specific part number. You can then search online or check with the manufacturer’s parts department to order genuine replacement racks. Provide the make, model number, and part number for your toaster oven to ensure you receive the correct racks.

When installing new racks, reference your toaster oven’s manual for proper placement and orientation. The racks usually slide easily into the side rails of the toaster oven. Make sure the new racks are level for the best results. Test the new racks with a dry run at a high temperature before using them to cook food. This will burn off any manufacturing oils and ensure they are heating properly.

With replacement racks designed specifically for your toaster oven model, you can feel confident restoring your appliance to optimal performance. Properly functioning racks are essential for even cooking, browning, and broiling. Keep some spare racks on hand so you always have fully working racks ready when needed. Your toaster oven is a workhorse appliance, so providing it with genuine parts for replacement will keep it functioning well for years to come.

Doors: Sealing in Heat and Keeping Energy Efficiency

The door on your toaster oven plays an important role in containing heat and maintaining energy efficiency. If your door is damaged or not sealing properly, it’s time for a replacement.

Finding the Right Door

You’ll want to purchase a door specifically designed for your make and model. The exact part number may be listed in your owner’s manual or on the product spec sheet. If not, check with the manufacturer’s parts department—they should be able to look up the right door for your unit based on the model number.

Aftermarket doors may seem tempting due to a lower price, but they often don’t fit precisely and won’t provide an adequate seal. For the best performance, stick with genuine replacement parts from the original manufacturer or an authorized parts supplier.

Installing the New Door

Once you have the proper replacement door in hand, installation is usually pretty straightforward. However, it’s best to refer to the documentation for your specific model for detailed steps. In general:

  1. Unplug the toaster oven and allow it to cool completely. This is important for safety and to avoid damage to internal components.
  2. Remove any screws, clips or brackets holding the existing door in place. These may be located along the top, bottom or sides of the opening.
  3. Lift out the old door. Clean the opening and seal area around it to remove any debris.
  4. Position the new door in the opening. Secure it in place using the screws, clips or brackets you removed previously. Ensure the door is level and seals fully against the opening.
  5. Test the new door to ensure it opens, closes and latches properly. Plug in the toaster oven and turn it on to verify it is heating as expected with no issues.
  6. Dispose of the old door properly according to the local regulations in your area.

With a properly installed replacement door, your toaster oven should be back to operating at maximum efficiency and providing perfectly toasted results once again. Be sure to refer to your owner’s manual for any model-specific care and maintenance instructions to keep your appliance running its best for years to come.

Crumb Trays: Catching Crumbs and Making Cleanup Easy

The crumb tray in your toaster oven serves an important purpose—it catches all the crumbs, drips, and spills to keep your oven clean while cooking. Without a properly fitted crumb tray, you’ll end up with a messy oven and burnt bits of food at the bottom that can negatively impact performance and create smoke.

Find the Right Size

Crumb trays come in different sizes to fit specific toaster oven models. Measure your existing crumb tray or the bottom of your toaster oven cavity to determine the correct size you need. The crumb tray should sit level and fit snugly but still be easy to remove and clean. An improperly sized crumb tray won’t catch crumbs effectively and can be a fire hazard.

Material Matters

Most crumb trays are made of durable, heat-resistant materials like aluminum, stainless steel or enameled steel. Aluminum and steel trays tend to be more affordable but can dent or rust over time with rough handling or exposure to moisture. Enameled steel and stainless steel trays are more durable and resistant to damage. For the best performance, choose a crumb tray made of the same or similar material as your toaster oven cavity.

Remove and Clean Regularly

To keep your toaster oven in good working order, remove and empty the crumb tray after every 2-3 uses or when it’s about 1/2 to 2/3 full. Wipe down the tray with a damp cloth or sponge to remove stuck on bits. For stuck on spills, use a paste of baking soda and water and scrub with a non-abrasive sponge or scrubber. Rinse well with water and dry completely before replacing in your toaster oven.

With regular removal and cleaning, your crumb tray will help keep your toaster oven sparkling clean and working like new. Neglecting crumb tray care is one of the top reasons for toaster ovens malfunctioning or catching on fire. So take a few minutes after cooking to empty, wipe down and properly maintain this important accessory. Your toaster oven and cooking results will thank you!

Replacement Bulbs: Illuminating Your Toaster Oven

When it’s time to replace the bulbs in your toaster oven, using genuine replacement parts is key. The bulbs provide illumination so you can see your food cooking, and the right bulbs will ensure optimal and safe performance.

Bulb specifications

For most toaster ovens, a standard 40-watt appliance bulb will work well and provide plenty of light. However, check your toaster oven’s manual for the specific bulb type and wattage recommended by the manufacturer. Using a bulb that’s too high in wattage can lead to overheating, while a bulb that’s too low won’t provide enough light. It’s best to stick as close as possible to the wattage listed in the specs.

Easy installation

Replacing the bulbs in your toaster oven is usually a simple task that requires no tools. Let the oven cool completely, then locate the bulb cover, typically on the back or top of the unit. Twist or unscrew to remove the cover. The bulb will be visible – gently pull it straight out to remove it from the socket. Hold the new replacement bulb by its base, line up the pins, and push it straight into the socket until snug. Put the cover back on, and you’re done. Most hardware stores that sell appliances will also stock toaster oven bulbs, or you can find them online using the specifications from your manual.

Maintaining brightness

For the best visibility, change your toaster oven bulbs once a year or if you notice them becoming dim. Dull bulbs won’t provide enough light for you to clearly see your food, and the lower light levels could affect cooking performance. Keeping fresh, bright bulbs installed is an easy way to help ensure optimal, long-lasting function of your toaster oven. Using genuine replacement parts recommended for your specific model will guarantee compatibility and the best results.

With the proper replacement bulbs installed, your toaster oven will be back to illuminating your cooking and browning your bread. Enjoy many more meals prepared just the way you like!

Timers: Keeping Track for Perfectly Baked Goods

The timer on your toaster oven is responsible for keeping track of how long foods have been baking or toasting so you get perfect results every time. Without a properly functioning timer, your toast could burn or your casseroles end up underdone.

Replacing a Faulty Timer

If your toaster oven timer is no longer keeping accurate time or has stopped working altogether, it’s best to replace it. You’ll want to purchase a timer that is specifically compatible with your toaster oven make and model. Generic timers may not connect properly or have the correct temperature range for your appliance.

To install a new timer, first unplug your toaster oven and allow it to cool completely. Locate the mounting screws or brackets securing the existing timer—this is typically found on the back or side of the oven. Remove the screws or brackets and disconnect any wiring. The new timer will come with instructions for proper installation, but it essentially involves securing the new timer in the same spot, connecting the color-coded wiring, and testing to ensure it’s working properly.

Once installed, set the new timer as directed for your usual baking and toasting needs. Be sure to keep an eye on the oven the first few times you use it to ensure the new timer is keeping accurate time. If it’s off, you may need to make minor adjustments to the timer or replace it again. With a fully functional timer, your toaster oven should bake, toast and broil as well as it did when new.

Related Parts

Other parts that commonly need replacement in toaster ovens include:

  • Heating elements – Responsible for generating the heat to bake and toast. Faulty elements will result in uneven or inefficient heating.
  • Thermostats – Control the oven temperature. Malfunctioning thermostats can lead to overheating or lack of heat.
  • Racks – Hold foods in the proper position for even heating. Warped or damaged racks won’t hold food securely and may need replacement.
  • Knobs and dials – Allow you to set temperatures, time and functions. Worn out or broken knobs and dials must be replaced to properly operate the oven.
  • Fuses – Prevent power surges that could damage the oven. Blown fuses cut off power and will need to be replaced.

Replacing parts as needed will help keep your toaster oven in working condition for many more batches of baked goods and toast to come.

Toaster Oven Parts FAQs: Common Questions Answered

Many common questions come up when it comes to toaster oven parts and maintenance. Here are some of the FAQs we often hear, along with helpful answers.

How often should I replace parts?

As a general rule of thumb, you’ll want to inspect and potentially replace certain parts of your toaster oven every 1 to 3 years to keep it running optimally. The heating elements, in particular, naturally degrade over time and with frequent use. If your toaster oven seems to be taking longer to preheat or is not cooking as evenly, it’s probably time for new heating elements.

Where can I find replacement parts?

The best place to find genuine replacement parts for your specific toaster oven model is directly from the manufacturer’s website or an authorized retailer. Make sure any parts you purchase are expressly listed as compatible with your toaster oven to ensure proper function and fit. Generic or “universal” parts may not work as well and could even be unsafe.

What parts typically need replacement?

The parts most commonly in need of replacement for toaster ovens include:

  • Heating elements – Responsible for generating the heat. Prone to burning out over time.
  • Thermostats – Controls the oven’s temperature. Can lose accuracy or break down with prolonged use.
  • Racks – Can become misshapen or damaged from high heat and frequent handling.
  • Knobs and dials – Get loose or break over time. Important for controlling settings.
  • Door parts – Such as hinges, latches, and seals. Can weaken or break from repeated opening/closing and exposure to high heat.
  • Interior light bulbs – Typically standard appliance bulbs that will eventually burn out. Easy to replace when needed.
  • Crumb trays – Collect crumbs and spills but need periodic replacement for proper functioning and hygiene.
  • Power cords – Although rare, the power cord can potentially fray or become damaged, in which case replacement is critical for safety.

By inspecting and replacing parts like the heating elements, thermostats, door parts as needed, you can keep your trusty toaster oven running like new for many years to come. Be sure to unplug the unit and allow all parts to cool completely before attempting to replace anything. With some basic tools and the proper replacement parts, you’ll have your toaster oven fixed up in no time!


So there you have it. With the right genuine replacement parts, you can get your trusty toaster oven back up and running like new in no time. Why settle for cheap knock-off parts that don’t fit right and end up causing more headaches down the road? Do yourself and your toaster oven a favor by investing in the real deal. Your taste buds and your wallet will thank you for it when your toaster oven is toasting and baking like a champ for years to come. Happy cooking and happy munching! May your toast always be the perfect shade of golden brown.