5 Must-Have Toaster Oven Pans for Delicious Results

As the owner of a toaster oven, you know this handy countertop appliance can do so much more than just toast bread. A toaster oven is ideal for baking, broiling, and reheating a variety of foods. However, to get the best results from your toaster oven recipes, you need the proper pans and tools. Having the right toaster oven pans and accessories makes it easy to achieve delicious outcomes and expand the range of foods you can cook in your toaster oven.

In this article, you’ll discover five Must-Have Toaster Oven Pans to add to your kitchen. With the right pans for your toaster oven on hand, you’ll be able to bake cookies, roast vegetables, broil fish filets, melt cheese on sandwiches, and so much more. The right pans, combined with some simple recipes, can help you get the most out of your countertop toaster oven and open up new possibilities for quick and easy homemade meals. Read on to find out which pans are essential for any toaster oven owner.

Toaster Oven Pans

Toaster Oven Pans

Toaster Oven Pans: Why You Need Them

Toaster ovens are convenient countertop appliances, but to get the most out of them, you’ll need some essential pans and tools. Quality toaster oven pans allow you to bake, roast, and broil a variety of foods with delicious results.

Toaster Oven Pans: Must-Haves

For basic baking, a standard baking pan is indispensable. Look for a pan specifically designed for toaster ovens, around 9 inches by 9 inches. These distribute heat evenly for perfect cookies, brownies, and more. Nonstick coatings prevent sticking and make cleanup a breeze.

A roasting pan with a roasting rack allows you to make succulent roasts, whole chickens, and vegetables. The rack elevates the food from the pan bottom, allowing air circulation for even cooking and a crispy exterior. For easy cleanup, choose a pan with a nonstick coating and a rack that fits securely inside.

For broiling fish filets, chicken breasts, or steak, a broiler pan with slots is ideal. The slots allow grease and fat to drip down, preventing the food from stewing. Look for a pan with an enameled or nonstick coating to prevent sticking.

For reheating leftovers, a casserole dish or pan is useful. Choose a size that fits comfortably in your toaster oven and is oven safe to at least 350 F. Glass or ceramic dishes distribute heat well and can go straight from oven to table.

With the right pans and tools, you’ll be cooking up a storm in your toaster oven. Well-chosen pans that fit properly and are designed for high-heat cooking will yield perfect results for years to come. Your toaster oven will become one of your most-used appliances!

5 Must-Have Toaster Oven Pans for Delicious Results

Unlock the potential of your toaster oven with the right pans. Explore a range of essential toaster oven pans that are perfect for cooking delicious recipes and making your meal preparation effortless.

Toaster Oven Pans

Toaster Oven Pans

Essential Toaster Oven Pan #1: Air Fryer Basket – For Healthy Frying

For perfect results from your toaster oven, the right pans and accessories are essential. One of the most useful is an air fryer basket. This allows you to make healthy “fried” foods like french fries, chicken wings, and onion rings.

An air fryer basket is a mesh basket that allows maximum air circulation so you can achieve a crispy, fried finish using little or no oil. The hot air is able to circulate freely around the food, cooking it evenly and giving it a golden, crispy exterior. Using an air fryer basket in your toaster oven means you can enjoy fried favorites without the excess fat and calories.

When shopping for an air fryer basket, look for one specifically meant for use in toaster ovens. It should be made of metal, preferably aluminum or stainless steel, for even heating and easy cleanup. A nonstick coating is helpful for easy release of foods and simplified cleaning. The basket should have an easy-grip handle and be the proper size to fit in your toaster oven while still allowing for good airflow.

To use an air fryer basket, simply add a small amount of oil (around 1 tablespoon for fries) and toss to coat the food evenly. Add the food to the basket, place it in your preheated toaster oven, and cook at a high temperature, around 400 F, shaking the basket once during cooking, until the food is crispy and cooked through. Check on the food frequently to prevent overcooking.

Using an air fryer basket is a great way to expand the versatility of your toaster oven and make healthier “fried” foods at home. Crispy, delicious results without the excess fat – what’s not to love? An air fryer basket is a must-have accessory that will have you enjoying all your fried food favorites in a healthier way.

Essential Toaster Oven Pan #2: Broiler Pan – For Perfect Broiling

To achieve optimal results when broiling in your toaster oven, a broiler pan is essential. A broiler pan allows grease and drippings to flow away from the food as it cooks, preventing a grease fire. It also helps contain any splattering that may occur.

Find a Pan That Fits Your Toaster Oven

Look for a broiler pan specifically designed for toaster ovens or small ovens. Standard broiler pans for full-size ovens will not fit properly in a toaster oven and will prevent heat from circulating effectively. Choose a pan with slots or a grate at the bottom to allow grease and fat to drip down, and a catch pan below to contain the drippings. Nonstick coatings can help prevent stuck-on bits of food and make cleanup easier.

Add Water to the Catch Pan

For extra precaution against grease fires, add an inch or two of water to the catch pan below the grate. The water will absorb the grease drippings and prevent flare-ups. Be very careful removing the broiler pan from the toaster oven, as the water will be extremely hot. Empty and wash the pan after each use to prevent grease buildup.

Broil on High Heat

To get good browning and flavor when broiling, use the highest temperature setting on your toaster oven. Place the broiler pan on the highest rack position, about 2 to 3 inches from the heating element. This proximity to the high, direct heat will produce optimal browning and caramelization.

Flip Halfway Through

For even cooking and the best results, flip meat, poultry or seafood pieces halfway through the broiling time. Use tongs to carefully flip each piece. Broil in batches if needed, so you have enough room to access all of the pieces. Watch the food closely, as broiling at high heat means it can burn quickly.

Using a proper broiler pan will allow you to achieve delicious, flavorful results when broiling in your toaster oven. With the correct pan and a few tips, you’ll be enjoying juicy, well-browned broiled dishes in no time.

Essential Toaster Oven Pan #3: Pizza Pan – For Homemade Pizza

A pizza pan is one of the most versatile pans you can have for a toaster oven. It allows you to make homemade personal pizzas quickly and easily. Look for a pan specifically designed for toaster ovens that is around 9 to 11 inches in diameter and 1 inch deep.

Non-Stick Coating

A non-stick coating like silicone or ceramic is ideal for a toaster oven pizza pan. It will prevent the dough from sticking as it bakes and make cleanup much easier. Avoid pans with a Teflon or PTFE coating, as these can release toxic fumes when overheated in a toaster oven.

Vented Base

A vented or perforated base is important for a toaster oven pizza pan. It will allow heat to circulate under the crust for even baking and a crispy bottom. Holes or slits in the base also prevent excess moisture from building up, which can lead to a soggy crust.


Handles on a toaster oven pizza pan make it easy to pull the pan out of the oven and transfer the pizza. Look for stay-cool handles that won’t get too hot to handle with your bare hands. Handles also make the pan easier to maneuver when placing raw pizza dough on it and removing the finished pizza.

Additional Uses

A pizza pan has more uses than just pizza. You can also use it to bake flatbreads, biscuits, scones, cookies, and other pastries in your toaster oven. For extra versatility, look for a pan with a nonstick coating and vented base, which will work well for a variety of baked goods. With the right tools and recipes, you’ll be making lots of delicious treats in your toaster oven.

In summary, a high-quality pizza pan is one of the most useful pans you can own for a toaster oven. Look for a pan with a nonstick coating, vented base, stay-cool handles, and dimensions suitable for most toaster ovens. With the right pizza pan, homemade pizza, flatbreads, and other tasty treats are just minutes away.

Essential Toaster Oven Pan #4: Baking Pan – For Cakes, Cookies and More

A baking pan is essential for making cakes, cookies, brownies and other tasty treats in your toaster oven. Look for a pan specifically designed for toaster ovens to ensure the best results.


Choose a pan that will fit comfortably in your toaster oven while still being large enough for standard recipes. An 8-inch square or 9-inch round pan is a versatile size that will work for most toaster ovens and recipes. Be sure to check your toaster oven’s interior dimensions to determine the largest size that will fit.


For the most even cooking, choose a pan made of heavy-gage aluminized steel or aluminum. These metals conduct heat well and will produce nicely browned crusts and edges. Non-stick coatings can release toxic fumes at high heat, so avoid using them.


Handles that extend beyond the edges of the pan can be awkward or unsafe to use in a toaster oven. Look for a pan with handles that curve inward, lie flat against the rim of the pan or have silicone sleeves. Handles that are slightly recessed into the sides of the pan are also a good option.

Additional Uses

A basic baking pan can do more than just bake cakes and cookies. You can also use it to roast vegetables, make casseroles, bread puddings, cobblers and more. For extra versatility, look for a pan with a removable bottom that can also be used as a serving platter.

With the right baking pan, your toaster oven will become an indispensable tool for making all kinds of delicious baked goods and savory dishes. Be sure to consider the size, material and handle style to find a pan that suits your particular toaster oven model and needs. Happy baking!

Essential Toaster Oven Pan #5: Grill Pan – For Indoor Grilling

A grill pan is essential for making delicious grilled recipes in your toaster oven. These pans have raised ridges that allow excess grease and oils to drip down, resulting in food that is deliciously crispy on the outside yet still juicy on the inside.

Benefits of a Toaster Oven Grill Pan

A toaster oven grill pan offers several benefits over outdoor grilling:

  • Convenience. Grilling indoors means you can enjoy grilled flavors any time of year without having to venture outside.
  • Better temperature control. Toaster ovens provide more precise temperature control than most grills, allowing you to properly cook food without burning it.
  • Safety. There is no open flame, so grilling indoors eliminates the risks of fire or flare-ups.
  • Versatility. In addition to meat, seafood, and vegetables, a grill pan can also be used to make grilled sandwiches, quesadillas, and paninis.

What to Look For in a Toaster Oven Grill Pan

When shopping for a grill pan, consider the following:

• Material: Cast iron, aluminum, and stainless steel are all great options for grill pans. Cast iron provides excellent heat retention and gives food an authentic grilled texture. Stainless steel and aluminum are more affordable and distribute heat evenly.

• Raised ridges: Choose a pan with ridges that are high enough to lift food above excess grease but not so tall that they prevent browning. Ridges around 1/4 inch high are typical.

• Nonstick coating: A nonstick coating helps prevent food from sticking and makes cleanup easy. For the most health-conscious choice, look for a pan with a ceramic nonstick coating.

• Handles: Wide, sturdy handles that stay cool to the touch make the pan easy to maneuver in a toaster oven.

• Size: Select a pan that will fit in your specific toaster oven model. Rectangular or square pans typically fit better than round. Measure your oven’s interior before buying a new pan.

With the right grill pan, you’ll be enjoying delicious grilled dishes from your toaster oven in no time. Meat, seafood, sandwiches and more—the possibilities for indoor grilling are endless!

Toaster Oven Pan Materials: What’s Best?

When choosing pans for your toaster oven, the material is an important factor to consider. The right material can help you achieve delicious results and maximize the versatility of your toaster oven.


Aluminum pans are inexpensive, lightweight and excellent conductors of heat. Aluminum pans will heat up quickly in a toaster oven and produce evenly browned results. However, aluminum can react with acidic ingredients and impart a metallic taste. Aluminum pans also tend to warp over time with repeated heating and cooling. For most uses, aluminum pans are a budget-friendly option but may need to be replaced more often.

Stainless Steel

Stainless steel pans are durable, non-reactive and dishwasher safe. Stainless steel can handle high heat without warping and will last a lifetime. However, stainless steel is a poor conductor of heat and can lead to uneven cooking results in a toaster oven. For best results, choose stainless steel pans with an aluminum or copper core to help distribute heat. Stainless steel pans tend to be more expensive, but are worth the investment for frequent use.


Ceramic pans are non-reactive, scratch-resistant and dishwasher safe. Ceramic pans will not leach chemicals into food and can handle high heat. However, ceramic pans may crack if subjected to sudden temperature changes. Ceramic pans can also be heavy and more difficult to handle. For baking, roasting or reheating in a toaster oven, ceramic pans are a great eco-friendly choice.

Additional factors:

• Coated pans – Nonstick coatings can degrade at high heat, so avoid using coated pans for broiling. For baking or roasting, coated pans can work well but may need to be replaced more often.

• Glass – Glass pans can shatter in a toaster oven due to the uneven heat. Avoid using glass pans.

• Cast iron – Cast iron retains heat well but can damage the coating of a toaster oven. Avoid using cast iron pans.

In summary, for versatility and durability in a toaster oven, stainless steel and ceramic pans are your best options. With the proper care and maintenance, these pans will allow you to make delicious meals for years to come. Choose aluminum or coated pans for more casual use, but be prepared to replace them more frequently.

Caring for Your Toaster Oven Pans

To keep your toaster oven pans in top condition and producing optimal results, proper care and maintenance are essential. By following these simple guidelines, your pans will last longer and continue performing at their best.

Hand Washing

It is best to hand wash your toaster oven pans to prevent scratching them. Place them in warm, soapy water and scrub with a soft sponge or nylon scrubber to remove stuck-on bits of food. For stubborn residue, fill the pans with water and dish soap and let them soak before scrubbing. Rinse well with water to remove all soap. Avoid harsh abrasive cleaners that can damage the nonstick coating.


After washing, dry your pans immediately to prevent water spots. Air drying is ideal. You can also dry them with a soft cloth. Never stack pans together when drying, as this prevents air flow and can lead to water spots.


For pans with a nonstick coating, conditioning them regularly will help keep the coating in good shape. Apply a small amount of oil, such as canola or flaxseed oil, to the pan and spread it evenly with a paper towel. Wipe away any excess oil with another paper towel. Condition pans after every few uses or when water no longer beads on the surface.

Avoiding Overheating

Never preheat an empty pan in the toaster oven, as this can cause damage to the pan and any nonstick coating. The pan should only be heated when it contains food. Remove pans from the toaster oven as soon as cooking is complete to prevent overheating, which can cause foods to burn and stick to the pans.


When not in use, nest pans together and store them in a cool, dry spot away from direct heat. This prevents warping and keeps pans in top condition until their next use. Follow these care and maintenance tips and your pans will provide delicious results for years to come.

Toaster Oven Pans FAQ: Your Questions Answered

Toaster ovens can produce delicious results when paired with the proper pans and tools. The following are some of the most useful pans to have for your toaster oven to achieve the best outcomes.

Toaster Oven Pan

A basic toaster oven pan, also known as a broiler pan, is essential. It allows you to catch drippings from broiling and roasting while the perforated top allows for even cooking. Look for a pan specifically designed for toaster ovens to ensure proper fit. Nonstick coatings make cleanup simple.

Pizza Pan

A small pizza pan lets you make personal pizzas, frozen pizzas, and reheating slices in your toaster oven. Choose a pan with holes or a wire mesh bottom for crispy crusts. Ceramic or steel pans produce the best results.

Loaf Pan

For homemade bread, quick breads, and meatloaves, a miniature loaf pan sized for toaster ovens is ideal. Look for pans that are 2 to 3 inches deep and hold 1 to 2 pounds for a standard toaster oven.

Baking Sheet

A small baking sheet, or cookie sheet, allows you to make cookies, biscuits, crispy bacon, roasted veggies, and more in your toaster oven. Choose a sheet with a lip for easy handling and look for materials like aluminized steel that won’t warp under high heat.

Muffin Pan

For homemade muffins, cupcakes, quiches, and breakfast sandwiches, a 6-cup muffin pan is perfect for most toaster ovens. Nonstick, aluminized steel pans produce the best release and even browning.

The pans and tools you choose for your toaster oven have a significant impact on your cooking and baking results. Investing in high-quality, properly sized pans designed for toaster oven use will allow you to make the most of your toaster oven and achieve professional-level outcomes. Be sure to refer to your toaster oven’s specifications for maximum pan sizes to ensure proper fit and safe operation.


When it comes to making the most of your toaster oven, having the right pans and tools can make all the difference. With high-quality, toaster oven-friendly pans designed for specific tasks like baking cookies, roasting vegetables, or cooking a personal pizza, you’ll be creating delicious recipes in no time. Investing in a few essential pans will open up a world of possibilities and help you get the most value and versatility from your toaster oven. Whether you’re a novice cook just getting started or an experienced chef looking to expand your repertoire, the right toaster oven pans are key. So do yourself and your taste buds a favor – get equipped with the pans you need to make your toaster oven work for you. You’ll be whipping up homemade toasted sandwiches, mini frittatas, personal pizzas and more in no time, all from the convenience of your countertop.